SAP GRC vs. IAG: Understanding the Key Differences and Use Cases

SAP offers two robust solutions in enterprise security and compliance: SAP Governance, Risk, and Compliance (GRC) and SAP Cloud Identity and Access Governance (IAG). While both address access management, they have distinct strengths and applications. This blog post will delve into their differences, ideal use cases, and how they can complement each other.

SAP GRC: The Comprehensive On-Premise Suite

SAP GRC is a mature, on-premise suite of tools designed to manage risk, ensure compliance, and streamline access controls within SAP systems. Its key components include:

• SAP Access Control: Facilitates role-based access management, segregation of duties (SoD) analysis, risk mitigation, and user provisioning.
• SAP Process Control: Manages internal controls, automates compliance monitoring, and documents business processes.
• SAP Risk Management: Provides a framework for identifying, assessing, analyzing, and mitigating enterprise risks.

SAP IAG: The Cloud-Native Access Governance Solution

SAP Cloud IAG is a cloud-based solution built on the SAP Business Technology Platform (SAP BTP). Its primary focus is streamlining identity and access management in hybrid environments that combine cloud and on-premise systems. Key features of SAP IAG include:

• Access Requests and Provisioning: Self-service portal for access requests, automated approvals, and provisioning into cloud and on-premise systems.
• Access Risk Analysis: Leverages risk analysis engines to identify access violations across hybrid landscapes.
• Role Design: Tools for designing and maintaining roles based on business needs and access patterns.
• Access Certification: Periodic access reviews and certifications to ensure compliance.

Key Differences: GRC vs. IAG

FeatureSAP GRCSAP IAG

Deployment

On-premise

Cloud-based

Focus

SAP-centric governance, risk, and compliance

Access governance for hybrid cloud and on-premise environments

Scope

Comprehensive (risk, compliance, access control)

Primarily access management

Integration

Deep integration with SAP modules

Can integrate with both SAP and non-SAP systems

User Interface

Traditional SAP UI

Modern, intuitive, web-based user interface

drive_spreadsheetExport to Sheets

When to Choose Which

• SAP GRC is ideal when:
  • Your landscape is predominantly SAP-based.
  • You require in-depth control over compliance processes and risk management.
  • Deep customization for business processes and workflows is a priority.
• SAP IAG is ideal when:
  • You operate a hybrid environment with both cloud and on-premise systems.
  • It would help if you had a user-friendly and centralized solution for access governance across diverse systems.
  • Rapid deployment and cloud scalability are essential.

Hybrid Scenarios

Importantly, SAP GRC and SAP IAG aren’t mutually exclusive. They can be used together in a hybrid model:

• IAG Bridge: Using the IAG bridge scenario, SAP GRC Access Control can leverage IAG to manage access in cloud applications, perform risk analysis, and streamline role design.

Conclusion

SAP GRC and SAP IAG serve different yet complementary purposes within an organization’s security strategy. GRC remains the go-to for extensive SAP-based compliance and risk needs, while IAG excels at simplifying access governance in today’s complex hybrid IT environments. The optimal choice depends on your specific requirements and architectural landscape.